Using R in Nonparametric Statistics: Basic Table Analysis, Part Three, Using assocstats and collapse.table

A tutorial by D.M. Wiig

As discussed in a previous tutorial one of the most common methods displaying and analyzing data is through the use of tables. In this tutorial I will discuss setting up a basic table using R and exploring the use of the assocstats function to generate several commonly used nonparametric measures of association. The assocstats function will generate the association measures of the Phi-coefficient, the Contingency Coefficient and Cramer’s V, in addition to the Likelihood Ratio and Pearson’s Chi-Squared for independence. Cramer’s V and the Contigency Coefficient are commonly applied to r x c tables while the Phi-coefficient is used in the case of dichotomous variables in a 2 x 2 table.

To illustrate the use of assocstats I will use hypthetical data exploring the relationship between level of education and average annual income. Education will be measured using the nominal categories “High School”, “College”, and “Graduate”. Average annual income will be measured using ordinal categories and expressed in thousands:

“< 25”; “25-50”; “51-100” and “>100”

Frequency counts of individuals that fall into each category are numeric.

In the first example a 4 x 3 table created with hypothetical frequencies as shown below:

Income                                Education
(thousands)          High School   College   Graduate

<25                                    15                       8                  5

26-50                              12                       12                8

51-100                           10                       22                25

>100                                  5                       10                 32
The first table, table1, is entered into R as a data frame using the following commands:

#create 4 x 3 data frame
#enter table1 in frequency form
table1 <- data.frame(expand.grid(income=c(“<25″,”25-50″,”51-100″,”>100″), education=c(“HS”,”College”, “Graduate”)),count=c(15,12,10,5,8,12,22,10,5,8,25,32))

Check to make sure the data are in the right row and column categories. Notice that the data are entered in the ‘count’ list by columns.

> table1
income  education     count
1 <25             HS                  15
2 25-50        HS                  12
3 51-100     HS                 10
4 >100          HS                   5
5 <25             College         8
6 25-50        College        12
7 51-100     College        22
8 >100          College        10
9 <25             Graduate      5
10 25-50     Graduate      8
11 51-100   Graduate    25
12 >100       Graduate    32

If the stable structure looks correct generate the table, tab1, using the xtabs function:

> #create table tab1 from data.frame
> tab1 <- xtabs(count ~income + education, data=table1)
Show the table using the command:

income         HS College Graduate
<25                   15     8             5
25-50             12     12           8
51-100          10     22          25
>100                 5     10          32
Use the assocstats function to generate measures of association for the table. Make sure that you have loaded the vcd package and the vcdExtras packages. Run assocstats with the following commands:

> assocstats(tab1)
X^2 df P(> X^2)
Likelihood Ratio 31.949 6 1.6689e-05
Pearson 32.279 6 1.4426e-05

Phi-Coefficient : 0.444
Contingency Coeff.: 0.406
Cramer’s V : 0.314

The measures show an association between the two variables. My intent is not to provide an analysis of how to evaluate each of the measures. There are excellent sources of documention on each measure of association in the R CRAN Literature. Since the Phi-coefficient is designed primarily to measure association between dichotomous variables in a 2 x 2 table,collapse the 4 x 3 table using the collapse.table function to get a more accurate Phi-coefficient. Since we want to go from a 4 x 3 to a 2 x 2 table we essentially collapse the table in two stages. The first stage collapses the table to a 2 x 3 table by combining the “<25” with the “25-50” and the “51-100” with the “>100” categories of income.

The resulting 2 x 3 table is seen below:

Income                High School      College        Graduate

<50                                 27                        20                    13

>50                                15                        32                     57

To collapse the table use the R function collapse.table to combine the “<25” and “26-50” categories and the “50-100” and “>100” categories as discussed above:

> #collapse table tab1 to a 2 x 3 table, table2
> table2 <-collapse.table(tab1, income=c(“<50″,”<50″,”>50″,”>50″))

View the resulting table, table2, with:

> table2
income          HS        College       Graduate
<50                  27             20                   13
>50                  15             32                   57

Now collapse the table to a 2 x 2 table by combining the “College” and “Graduate” columns:
> #collapse 2 x 3 table2 to a 2 x2 table, table3
> table3 <-collapse.table(table2, education=c(“HS”,”College”,”College”))

View the resulting table, table3, with:

> table3
income             HS             College
<25                     27                  33
>100                  15                  89

Use the assocstats function to evaluated the 2 x 2 table:

> #use assocstats on the 2 x 2 table, table3
> assocstats(table3)
X^2 df P(> X^2)
Likelihood Ratio 18.220 1 1.9684e-05
Pearson 18.673 1 1.5519e-05

Phi-Coefficient : 0.337
Contingency Coeff.: 0.32
Cramer’s V : 0.337

There are many other table manipulation function available in the R vcd and vcdExtras packages and well as other packages to provide analysis of nonparametric data. This series of tutorials hopefully serves to illustrate some of the more basic and common table functions using these packages. The next tutorial looks at the use of the ca function to perform and graph the results of a basic Correspondence Analysis.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.